The house at 405 Maple Avenue in Cheshire was built c. 1790, but has been much altered from its original appearance. The book Old Historic Homes of Cheshire (1895), complied by Edwin R. Brown, states that “built by Col. Benjamin Hall for his son Benjamin, about 100 years ago,” but then notes
Benjamin Hall. Jr., for whom this house was erected, married Mary Ives in 1752. He graduated from Yale College in 1754. He was highly honored and esteemed as a citizen. He died in the year 1786, aged 50 years, at the very zenith of his usefulness.
The book also mentions later owners:
Here, also, William Law, the grandfather of Dr. William Law, resided for many years. He was a prominent official of the town, was selectman several years. and representative from this town in the years 1786, 1802, 1806, 1808 and 1809. A meeting of the Consociation of New Haven County was held at his house, November 14, 1786, he being one of those who were disaffected by the pastorate of the Rev. John Foote.
Chas. K. Brown, Wm, Spencer, Selden Spencer, and Franklin Howard have been owners of these premises, and have resided here with their families during these later years. Elizur P. Atwater purchased this property in the year 1873, and since that time has resided here. The farm connected with this place is considered one of the best in the town.
The Cheshire Grange was organized at the Atwater House in 1885 and its meetings were held there until a Grange Hall was erected in 1891. In 1957, the house was used at a convent for nuns who taught at St. Bridgid School. Today the building is home to Guardian Angels Homecare.