Judge Joseph Eaton House (1725)

At 20 Academy Hill Road in Plainfield is a colonial house, built in 1725, which now for sale for use as a bed & breakfast. The house served as both residence and probate court of Judge Joseph Eaton. A market listing for the house claims that it was also the Eaton Tavern (later known as the the Plainfield Hotel and the Lafayette Inn), where George Washington (1776 and 1781) and Lafayette (1824) once stayed. Other sources clearly state that Eaton’s Tavern (1768), which is no longer standing, was actually located at the intersection of Gallup Street and Norwich Road.

The Rev. Elizur Goodrich House (1763)

The Reverend Elizur Goodrich was the second minister of Durham’s Congregational Church, from 1756 until his death in 1797. He was born in Rocky Hill in 1734 and was prepared for Yale by Rev. James Lockwood of Wethersfield. Rev. Goodrich would later prepare students for Yale himself, including Eli Whitney. Rev. Goodrich was a contemporary and supporter of Ezra Stiles, minister, theologian and educator, who was president of Yale from 1778 to 1795. Both men were among Connecticut’s intellectual leaders of the time. Elizur Goodrich the minister was the father of Elizur Goodrich the lawyer and politician. The minister’s house, on Main Street in Durham, was built in 1763. Around 1840, Goodrich’s heirs sold the house to Zebulon Hale and Enos Rogers, who ran a nearby store. Zebulon’s daughter, Olive, married Watson Davis, who replaced Rogers as his father-in-law’s partner in the store. The house remained in the Davis family well into the twentieth century.

James Wadsworth House (1708)

James Wadsworth (1675-1756) was a lawyer from Farmington, who moved to Durham in 1707 with his wife, Ruth Noyes. Wadsworth, who became colonel of the Tenth Regiment of militia, also served as Town Clerk, Justice of the Peace, Speaker of House of the Colonial Assembly and Judge of the Superior Court. Wadsworth’s grandson later held the same offices: the Wadsworth family dominated local politics for eighty years. Col. Wadsworth’s house in Durham began as a single-story center-chimney house, built in 1708, and was expanded to two stories between 1720 and 1750.

Hanford-Silliman House (1764)

Stephen Hanford was a weaver and New Canaan’s first licensed tavern keeper. In 1764, he moved into a new house with his new wife, Jemima. The house was both his home and an “ordinary,” or inn and tavern. After his wife died in 1784, Hanford sold the house to Elisha Leeds, who gave it to his daughter Martha, and her husband, Joseph Silliman, as a wedding present. The Hanford-Silliman House remained in the Silliman family into the 1920s. Acquired by the New Canaan Historical Society in 1957, it now one of their museum properties.

The Anderson House (1702)

The Anderson House, at 1380 Enfield Street in Enfield, was built in 1702 by original settlers of the town. Later in the eighteenth century, the house was owned by Ephraim Pease, grandson of Deacon Robert Pease, one of the two founders of Enfield, who came from Salem, Massachusetts. Ephraim Pease was a merchant, slave owner and representative in the General Assembly. It’s possible that George Washington once slept in the house, which also held Hessian prisoners during the Revolutionary War. The house was later in a dilapidated condition but was eventually restored.

Dr. Reuben Smith House (1770)

On North Street in Litchfield is a house built in 1770 for Dr. Reuben Smith and his new wife, Abigail Hubbard. Next to Dr. Smith’s home was his Apothecary Shop, later moved to Litchfield Green. The house is one of three on North Street known to have been constructed by the well-known builder of churches, Giles Kilborn of Bantam. The structure was altered in the nineteenth century, when the original central chimney was removed. It has since been reconstructed. The house has recently been for sale.